Open Access
Subscription Access
Evidence-based or person-centered? An ontological debate
Abstract
Evidence-based medicine (EBM) continues to be vigorously debated and person-centered healthcare (PCH) has been proposed as an improvement. But is PCH offered as a supplement to or as a replacement of EBM? Prima facie PCH only concerns the practice of medicine, while the contended features of EBM also include specific methods and the biomedical model. In this paper I argue that there are good philosophical reasons to see PCH as a radical alternative to the existing medical paradigm of EBM, since the two seem committed to conflicting ontologies. I will aim to make explicit some of the most fundamental assumptions that motivate EBM and PCH in order to show that the choice between them ultimately comes down to ontological preference. While EBM has a solid foundation in positivism, or what I here call Humeanism, PCH is more consistent with causal dispositionalism. I conclude that if there is a paradigmatic revolution on the way in medicine, it is first of all one of ontology.
Keywords
References
Kuhn, T. (1962). The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
WHO - World Health Organization. (2007). People-Centred Health Care: A policy framework, Manila: WHO Regional Office for the Western Pacific, http://iris.wpro.who.int/handle/10665.1/5420.
Hickey, D.S. (2012). The failure of evidence-based medicine? European Journal for Person Centered Healthcare 1 (1) 69-79.
Wyller, T.B. (2011). Evidensbasert medisin eller vulgærcochranisme? Tidsskrift for den Norske Legeforening 131, 1181-1182.
Rothwell, P.M. (2005). External validity of randomised controlled trials: to whom do the results of this trial apply? Lancet 365 (9453) 82-93.
Hjelmesæth, J. (2014). Randomised studies - useful for whom? Tidsskrift for den Norske Legeforening 19, 134.
Berkwits, M. & Aronowitz, R. (1995). Different questions beg different methods. Journal of General Internal Medicine 10 (7) 409-410.
Greaves, D. & Evans, M. (2000). Medical humanities. Medical Humanities 26, 1-2.
Macnaughton, J. (2011). Medical humanities’ challenge to medicine. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 17 (5) 927-932.
Broom, B.C. (2000). Somatic Illness and the Patient’s Other Story. London: Free Association Books.
Getz, L., Kirkengen, A.L. & Ulvestad, E. (2011). The human biology - saturated with experience. Tidsskrift for den Norske Legeforening 131, 683-687.
Greenhalgh, T. & Hurwitz, B. (eds.). (1998). Narrative Based Medicine. Dialogue and Discourse in Clinical Practice. London: BMJ Books.
Kirkengen, A.L. (2001). Inscribed Bodies. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Glennan, S.S. (1997). Probable causes and the distinction between subjective and objective chance. Nôus 31, 496-519.
Russo, F. & Williamson, J. (2007). Interpreting causality in the health sciences. International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 21 (2) 1157-1170.
Clarke, B., Gillies, D., Illari, P., Russo, F. & Williamson, J. (2013). The evidence that evidence-based medicine omits. Preventive Medicine 57 (6) 745-747.
Clarke, B., Gillies, D., Illari, P., Russo, F. & Williamson, J. (2014). Mechanisms and the Evidence Hierarchy. Topoi 33 (2) 339-360.
Thornquist, E. & Kirkengen, A.L. (2015). The quantified self: closing the gap between general knowledge and particular case? Journal of Clinical Evaluation in Practice 21, 398-403.
Getz, L. (2006). Sustainable and Responsible Preventive Medicine, Doctoral thesis, Trondheim: Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Faculty of Medicine, Department of Public Health and General Practice.
Parekh, A.K. & Barton, M.B. (2010). The challenge of multiple comorbidity for the US health care system. Journal of the American Medical Association 303 (13) 1303-1304.
Vogt, H., Ulvestad, E., Eriksen, T.E. & Getz, L. (2014). Getting personal: can systems medicine integrate scientific and humanistic conceptions of the patient? Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 20 (6) 942-952.
Engel, G.L. (1977). The need for a new medical model: a challenge for biomedicine. Science 196 (4286) 129-136.
Butler, C.C., Evans, M., Greaves, D. & Simpson, S. (2004). Medically unexplained symptoms: the biopsychosocial model found wanting. Journal of Royal Society of Medicine 97, 219-222.
Eriksen, T.E., Kerry, R., Mumford, S., Lie, S.A.N. & Anjum, R.L. (2013). At the borders of medical reasoning: aetiological and ontological challenges of medically unexplained symptoms. Philosophy, Ethics, and Humanities in Medicine 8 (1) 1-11.
DeVault, D., Artstein, R., Benn, G., Dey, T., Fast, E., Gainer, A. & Lucas, G. (2014). SimSensei Kiosk: A virtual human interviewer for healthcare decision support. In: Proceedings of the 2014 international conference on Autonomous agents and multi-agent systems, International Foundation for Autonomous Agents and Multiagent Systems, pp. 1061-1068.
Vogt, H. & Pahle, A.S. (2015). Likeverd på samlebånd. Morgenbladet 11 September 2015, http://morgenbladet.no/ideer/2015/09/likeverd-pa-samleband.
Miles, A. (2009). On a medicine of the whole person: away from scientistic reductionism and towards the embrace of the complex in clinical practice. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 15, 941-949.
Miles, A. & Asbridge, J. (2013). The European Society for Person Centered Healthcare. European Journal for Person Centered Healthcare 1 (1) 4-40.
Loughlin, M., Bluhm, R., Stoyanov, D.S., Buetow, S., Upshur, R.E., Borgerson, K., Goldenberg, M.J. & Kingma, E. (2013). Explanation, understanding, objectivity and experience. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 19 (3) 415-421.
Hume, D. (1739). A Treatise of Human Nature. Selby-Bigge, L.B. (ed.). Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1888.
Howick, J. (2011). The Philosophy of Evidence-Based Medicine. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.
Howick, J., Glasziou, P. & Aronson, J.K. (2009). The evolution of evidence hierarchies: what can Bradford Hill’s ‘guidelines for causation’ contribute? Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 102, 186-194.
Doll, R. & Hill, A.B. (1954). The mortality of doctors in relation to their smoking habits; a preliminary report. British Medical Journal 1, 1451-1455.
Hume, D. (1748). An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding. Millican, P. (ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007.
Broadbent, A. (2013). Philosophy of Epidemiology. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Aristotle. Metaphysics. Lawson-Tancred, H. (trans.). London: Penguin, 1998.
Spinoza, B. (1677). The Ethics. Elwes, R.H.M. (ed.). New York: Dover, 1955.
Kant, I. (1781). Critique of Pure Reason. Kemp Smith, N. (trans.). London: MacMillan, 1929.
Mill, J.S. (1843). A System of Logic. London: Parker.
Mackie, J.L. (1980). The Cement of the Universe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lewis, D. (1986). Philosophical Papers II. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Venn, J. (1866). The Logic of Chance. 4th edn. New York: Chelsea, 1962.
Fuller, J. & Flores, L.J. (2015). The Risk GP Model: The standard model of prediction in medicine. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 54, 49-61.
Lewis, D. (1986). On The Plurality of Worlds. Oxford: Blackwell.
Mumford, S. & Anjum, R.L. (2011). Getting Causes from Powers. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Harré, R. & Madden, E.H. (1975). Causal Powers: A Theory of Natural Necessity. Oxford: Blackwell.
Molnar, G. (2003). Powers: A Study in Metaphysics. Mumford, S. (ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Tyreman, S. (2006). Causes of illness in clinical practice: A conceptual exploration. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 9 (3) 285-291.
Broom, B.C. (2007). Meaning-full Disease. How Personal Experience and Meanings Cause and Maintain Physical Illness. London: Karnac Book Ltd.
Kirkengen, A.L. (2010). The Lived Experience of Violation. How Abused Children Become Unhealthy Adults. Bucharest: Zeta Books.
Kerry, R., Eriksen, T.E., Lie, S.A.N., Mumford, S.D. & Anjum, R.L. (2012). Causation and evidence‐based practice: an ontological review. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 18 (5) 1006-1012.
Greenhalgh, T., Howick, J. & Maskrey, N. (2014). Evidence based medicine: a movement in crisis? British Medical Journal 348, g3725.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5750/ejpch.v4i2.1152
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.