Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access

Patients’ views on using decision support tools: a systematic review

Annelies Engelen, Joke Vanderhaegen, Hendrik Van Poppel, Chantal Van Audenhove

Abstract


Background, aims and scope: Decision support tools assist patients in medical decision-making. However, implementing these tools in practice is challenging. We systematically reviewed barriers and facilitators to using decision support tools, as perceived by patients.

Methods: A systematic search of scientific articles was performed in MEDLINE, CENTRAL, EMBASE and CINHAL databases. Search strategies combined pre-defined free-text words and MeSH, or database equivalent, derived from the following broad topic areas: decision support tools, barriers and facilitators, use or implementation and user perceptions. Eligible studies qualitatively presented patients’ views on using tools. These views were thematically analyzed, starting from an existing taxonomy of barriers to and facilitators of the implementation of healthcare innovations.

Results: Electronic searches yielded a total of 7067 unique references; 365 full-text articles were retrieved, of which 33 publications met the inclusion criteria. Seven additional publications were included after reference searching. Key descriptive themes were classified in three broad categories of tool-, user- and environment-related barriers and facilitators. The most commonly identified themes were perceived usefulness, ease of use, the health professional-patient relationship, quality and quantity of information and need as motivation to use tools.

Conclusions: Patients express a need for decision support, but experience obstacles to using tools. The two most common, attitude-related, barriers to tool use were the perceived difficulty of using a tool and its dubious efficacy. The results of this review can support researchers in the design of development and evaluation strategies that specifically address the identified barriers and facilitators and thus further the implementation of decision support tools.


Keywords


decision support; implementation; patients

Full Text:

PDF

References


Guadagnoli, E. & Ward P. (1998). Patient participation in decision-making. Social Science & Medicine 47 (3) 329-339.

Coulter, A. (2010). Do patients want a choice and does it work? British Medical Journal 341, c4989.

Tariman, J.D., Berry, D.L., Cochrane, B., Doorenbos, A. & Schepp, K. (2010). Preferred and actual participation roles during health care decision making in persons with cancer: a systematic review. Annals of Oncology 21 (6) 1145-1151.

Kiesler, D.J. & Auerbach, S.M. (2006). Optimal matches of patient preferences for information, decision-making and interpersonal behavior: Evidence, models and interventions. Patient Education and Counseling 61 (3) 319-341.

Woolf, S.H., Chan. E.C.Y., Harris, R., Sheridan. S.L., Braddock, I.I.I., Kaplan, R.M., Krist, A., O’Connor, A.M. & Tunis, S. (2005). Promoting Informed Choice: Transforming Health Care To Dispense Knowledge for Decision Making. Annals of Internal Medicine 143 (4) 293-300.

Elwyn, G., Frosch, D., Thomson, R., Joseph-Williams, N., Lloyd, A., Kinnersley, P., Cording, E., Tomson, D., Dodd, C., Rollnick, S., Edwards, A. & Barry, M. (2012). Shared Decision Making: A Model for Clinical Practice. Journal of General Internal Medicine 27 (10) 1361- 367.

Charles, C., Gafni, A. & Whelan, T. (1997). Shared decision-making in the medical encounter: What does it mean? (or it takes at least two to tango). Social Science & Medicine 44 (5) 681-692.

Stewart, M., Brown, J., Weston, W., McWhinney, L., McWilliam, C. & Freeman, T. (1995). Patient-centred Medicine: Transforming the Clinical Method. London: Sage.

Légaré, F., Ratté, S., Stacey, D., Kryworuchko, J., Gravel, K., Graham, I.D. & Turcotte S. (2010). Interventions for improving the adoption of shared decision making by healthcare professionals. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. CD006732.pub2

Nelson, W.L., Han, P.K.J., Fagerlin, A., Stefanek, M. & Ubel, P.A. (2007). Rethinking the Objectives of Decision Aids: A Call for Conceptual Clarity. Medical Decision Making 27 (5) 609-618.

Stacey, D., Légaré, F., Col, N.F., Bennet, C.L., Barry, M.J., eden, K.B., Holmes-Rovner, M., Llewelly-Thomas, H., Lyddiatt, A., Thomson, R., Trvena, L. & Wu, J.H. (2014). Decision aids for people facing health treatment or screening decisions. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. CD001431.pub4

(12) Elwyn, G., O’Connor, A.M., Bennet, C., Newcombe, R.G., Politi, M., Durand, M.A., Drake, E., Joseph-Williams, N., Khangura, S., Saarimaki, A., Sivell, S., Stiel, M., Bernsteing, S.J., Col, N., Coulter, A., Eden, K., Harter, M., Rovner, M.H., Moumjid, N., Stacy, D., Thomsen, R., Whelan, T., van der Weijden, T. & Edwards, A. (2009). Assessing the quality of decision support technologies using the International Patient Decision Aid Standards instrument (IPDASi). PLoS ONE 4 (3) e4705.

Volk, R., Llewellyn-Thomas, H., Stacey, D. & Elwyn, G. (2013). Ten years of the International Patient Decision Aid Standards Collaboration: evolution of the core dimensions for assessing the quality of patient decision aids. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making 13 (Supplement 2) S1.

Marrin, K., Brain, K., Durand, M.A., Edwards, A., Lloyd, A., Thomas, V. & Elwyn, G. (2013). Fast and frugal tools for shared decision-making: how to develop Option Grids. European Journal for Person Centered Healthcare 1 (1) 240-245.

Légaré, F., O’Connor, A.M., Graham, I.D., Saucier, D., Côté, L., Blais, J., Cauchon, M. & Paré, L. (2006). Primary health care professionals’ views on barriers and facilitators to the implementation of the Ottawa Decision Support Framework in practice. Patient Education and Counseling 63 (3) 380-390.

Gagnon, M.P., Desmartis, M., Labrecque, M., Car, J., Pagliari, C., Pluye, P., Frémont, P., Gagnon, J., Tremblay, N. & Légaré, F. (2012). Systematic review of factors influencing the adoption of information and communication technologies by healthcare professionals. Journal of Medical Systems 36 (1) 241-277.

Elwyn, G., Scholl, I., Tietbohl, C., Mann, M., Edwards, A.G., Clay, C., Légaré, F., van der Weijden, T., Lewis, C.L., Wexler, R.M. & Frosch, D.L. (2013). "Many miles to go...": a systematic review of the implementation of patient decision support interventions into routine clinical practice. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making 13 (Supplement 2) S14.

Gravel, K., Légaré, F. & Graham, I. (2006). Barriers and facilitators to implementing shared decision-making in clinical practice: a systematic review of health professionals' perceptions. Implementation Science 1 (1) 16.

Légaré, F.S., Ratté, S., Gravel, K. & Graham, I. (2008). Barriers and facilitators to implementing shared decision-making in clinical practice: update of a systematic review of health professionals' perceptions. Patient Education and Counseling 73 (3) 526-535.

Joseph-Williams, N., Elwyn, G. & Edwards, A. (2014). Knowledge is power for patients: A systematic review and thematic synthesis of patient-reported barriers and facilitators to shared decision making. Patient Education and Counseling 94 (3) 291-309.

Dennis, C.L. & Chung-Lee L. (2006). Postpartum Depression Help-Seeking Barriers and Maternal Treatment Preferences: A Qualitative Systematic Review. Birth 33 (4) 323-331.

Gulliver, A., Griffiths, K. & Christensen, H. (2010). Perceived barriers and facilitators to mental health help-seeking in young people: a systematic review. BMC Psychiatry 10 (1) 113.

Elwyn, G., Frosch, D., Volandes, A., Edwards, A. & Montori, V. (2010). Investing in deliberation: a definition and classification of decision support interventions for people facing difficult health decisions. Medical Decision Making 30 (6) 701.

Mills, E.J., Nachega, J.B., Bangsberg, D.R., Singh, S., Rachlis, B., Wu, P., Wilson, K., Buchan, I., Gill, C.J. & Cooper, C. (2006). Adherence to HAART: A Systematic Review of Developed and Developing Nation Patient-Reported Barriers and Facilitators. PLoS Medicine 3 (11) e438.

Bunn, F., Dickinson, A., Barnett-Page, E., McInnes, E. & Horton, K. (2008). A systematic review of older people's perceptions of facilitators and barriers to participation in falls-prevention interventions. Ageing & Society 28 (04) 449-472.

Pluye, P. & Hong, Q.N. (2014). Combining the Power of Stories and the Power of Numbers: Mixed Methods Research and Mixed Studies Reviews. Annual Review of Public Health 35 (1) 29-45.

Davis, F.D. (1989). Perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, and user acceptance of information technology. MIS Quarterly 13 (3) 319-340.

Rogers, E.M. (2010). Diffusion of innovations. UK Online: Simon and Schuster.

McGinn, C.A., Grenier, S., Duplantie, J., Shaw, N., Sicotte, C., Mathieu, L., Leduc, Y., Légaré, F. & Gagnon, M.P. (2011). Comparison of user groups' perspectives of barriers and facilitators to implementing electronic health records: a systematic review. BMC Medicine 9 (1) 46.

Albrecht, K., Simon, D., Buchholz, A., Reuter, K., Frosch, D., Seebauer, L. & Härter, M. (2011). How does a German audience appraise an American decision aid on early stage breast cancer? Medical Decision Making 83, 58-63.

Ameling, J.M., Auguste, P., Ephraim, P.L., Lewis-Boyer, L., DePasquale, N., Greer, R.C., Crews, D.C., Powe, N.R., Rabb, H. & Boulware, E.L. (2012). Development of a decision aid to inform patients' and families' renal replacement therapy selection decisions. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making 12, 140.

Bhavnani, V., Clarke, A., Dowie, J., Kennedy, A. & Pell, I. (2002). Women's views of two interventions designed to assist in the prophylactic oophorectomy decision: a qualitative pilot evaluation. Health Expectations 5 (2) 156-171.

Boyd, L. & Archer, F. (2007). Developing a web-based education program for people with asthma in rural and remote areas. Available at: http://ro.ecu.edu.au/jephc/vol5/iss4/4 (last accessed 24 Juin 2015)

Brink, S.G., Birney, A.J. & McFarren, A.E. (2000). Charting your course: formative evaluation of a prostate cancer treatment decision aid. Available at: http://js.sagamorepub.com/gjhep/article/view/4099 (last accessed 24 Juin 2015)

Butow, P.N., Solomon, M., Young, J.M., Whelan, T., Salkeld, G., Wilson, K., Harrison, J.D., Hruby, G., Mamsour, O., Kennedy, N. & Tattersall, M.H. (2006). Consumer impact of an interactive decision aid for rectal cancer patients offered adjuvant therapy. Colorectal Disease 8 (8) 676-682.

Culver, J.O., MacDonald, D.J., Thornton, A.A., Sand, S.R., Grant, M., Bowen, D.J., Burke, H., Garcia, N., Metcalfe, K.A. & Wetizelf, J.N. (2011). Development and evaluation of a decision aid for BRCA carriers with breast cancer. Journal of Genetic Counseling 20 (3) 294-307.

D'Alimonte, L., Angus, J., Wong, J., Paszat, L., Soren, B. & Szumacher, E. (2012). Working toward a decision: The development and first impressions of a decision aid for older women with early-stage breast cancer. Journal of Medical Imaging and Radiation Sciences 43 (1) 60-65.

Dowding, D., Swanson, V., Bland, R., Thomson, P., Mair, C., Morrison, A,, Taylor, A., Beechey, C., Simpson, R. & Niven, K. (2004). The development and preliminary evaluation of a decision aid based on decision analysis for two treatment conditions: benign prostatic hyperplasia and hypertension. Patient Education and Counseling 52 (2) 209-215.

Durand, M.A., Wegwarth, O., Boivin, J. & Elwyn, G. (2012). Design and usability of heuristic-based deliberation tools for women facing amniocentesis. Health Expectations 15 (1) 32-48.

Frank, C., Pichora, D., Suurdt, J. & Heyland, D. (2010). Development and use of a decision aid for communication with hospitalized patients about cardiopulmonary resuscitation preference. Patient Education and Counseling 79 (1) 130-133.

Harwood, R., Douglas, C. & Clark, D. (2011). Decision aids for breast and nodal surgery in patients with early breast cancer: development and a pilot study. Asia-Pacific Journal of Clinical Oncology 7 (2) 114-122.

Holmes-Rovner, M., Stableford, S., Fagerlin, A., Wei, J.T., Dunn, R.L., Ohene-Frempong, J., Kelly-Blake, K. & Rovner, D.R. (2005). Evidence-based patient choice: a prostate cancer decision aid in plain language. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making 5, 16.

Jones, R.A., Steeves, R., Ropka, M.E. & Hollen, P. (2013). Capturing treatment decision making among patients with solid tumors and their caregivers. Oncology Nursing Forum 40 (1) E24-E31.

Juraskova, I., Butow, P., Lopez, A., Seccombe, M., Coates, A., Boyle, F., McCarthy, N., Reaby, L. & Forbes, J.F. (2008). Improving informed consent: pilot of a decision aid for women invited to participate in a breast cancer prevention trial (IBIS-II DCIS). Health Expectations 11 (3) 252-262.

Kline, C., Reineke, A., Auger, J.A., Willert, J., Roberts, W. & Schiff, D. (2012). Effects of a unique pediatric hematology-oncology palliative care program on medical decision-making and communication between healthcare providers and families: Results of a supportive care survey. Progress in Palliative Care 20 (1) 13-18.

Lenz, M., Kasper, J. & Muhlhauser, I. (2009). Development of a patient decision aid for prevention of myocardial infarction in type 2 diabetes - rationale, design and pilot testing. Psycho-Social Medicine 6, Doc05.

Li, L.C., Adam, P.M., Townsend, A.F., Lacaille, D., Yousefi, C., Stacey, D., Gromala, D., Shaw, C.D., Tugwell, P. & Backman, C.L. (2013). Usability testing of ANSWER: a web-based methotrexate decision aid for patients with rheumatoid arthritis. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making 13 (1), 131.

Matlock, D.D., Keech, T.A., McKenzie, M.B., Bronsert, M.R., Nowels, C.T. & Kutner, J.S. (2014). Feasibility and acceptability of a decision aid designed for people facing advanced or terminal illness: a pilot randomized trial. Health Expectations 17 (1) 49-59.

Newsome, A., Sieber, W., Smith, M. & Lillie, D. (2012). If you build it, will they come? A qualitative evaluation of the use of video-based decision aids in primary care. Available at: http://europepmc.org/abstract/med/22241338 (last accessed 24 Juin 2015).

Rashidian, H., Nedjat, S., Majdzadeh, R., Gholami, J., Haghjou, L., Abdollahi, B.S., Davatch, F. & Rashidian, A. (2013). The perspectives of iranian physicians and patients towards patient decision aids: a qualitative study. BMC Research Notes 6 (1) 379.

Reichlin, L., Mani, N., McArthur, K., Harris, A.M., Rajan, N. & Dacso, C.C. (2011). Assessing the acceptability and usability of an interactive serious game in aiding treatment decisions for patients with localized prostate cancer. Journal of Medical Internet Research 13 (1) e4.

Sawka, C.A., Goel, V., Mahut, C.A., Taylor, G.A., Thiel, E.C., O'Connor, A.M., Aclerùa, O., Burt, K.H. & Gort, E.H. (1998). Development of a patient decision aid for choice of surgical treatment for breast cancer. Health Expectations 1 (1) 23-36.

Sivell, S., Marsh, W., Edwards, A., Manstead, A.S., Clements, A. & Elwyn, G. (2012). Theory-based design and field-testing of an intervention to support women choosing surgery for breast cancer: BresDex. Patient Education and Counseling 86 (2) 179-188.

Smith, S.K., Trevena, L., Nutbeam, D., Barratt, A., McCaffery, K.J. (2008). Information needs and preferences of low and high literacy consumers for decisions about colorectal cancer screening: utilizing a linguistic model. Health Expectations 11 (2) 123-136.

Smith, S.K., Kearney, P., Trevena, L., Barratt, A., Nutbeam, D. & McCaffery, K.J. (2012). Informed choice in bowel cancer screening: a qualitative study to explore how adults with lower education use decision aids. Health Expectations 17 (4) 511-522.

Sorenson, J.R., Lakon, C., Spinney, T. & Jennings-Grant, T. (2004). Assessment of a decision aid to assist genetic testing research participants in the informed consent process. Genetic Testing 8 (3) 336-346..

Sundaresan, P., Turner, S., Kneebone, A., Pearse, M. & Butow, P. (2011). Evaluating the utility of a patient decision aid for potential participants of a prostate cancer trial (RAVES-TROG 08.03). Radiotherapy and Oncology 101 (3) 521-524.

Tiedje, K., Shippee, N.D., Johnson, A.M., Flynn, P.M., Finnie, D.M., Liesinger, J.T., May, C.R., Olson, M.E., Ridgeway, J.L., Shah, N.D., Yawn, B.P. & Montori, V.M. (2013). 'They leave at least believing they had a part in the discussion': understanding decision aid use and patient-clinician decision-making through qualitative research. Patient Education and Counseling 93 (1) 86-94.

Tracy, C.S., Dantas, G.C. & Upshur, R.E. (2004). Feasibility of a patient decision aid regarding disclosure of personal health information: qualitative evaluation of the Health Care Information Directive. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making 4 (1) 13.

Vogel, R.I., Petzel, S.V., Cragg, J., McClellan, M., Chan, D., Dickson, E., Jacko, J.A., Sainfort, F. & Geller, M.A. (2013). Development and pilot of an advance care planning website for women with ovarian cancer: a randomized controlled trial. Gynecologic Oncology 131 (2) 430-436.

Weiss, M.C., Montgomery, A.A., Fahey, T. & Peters, T.J. (2004). Decision analysis for newly diagnosed hypertensive patients: a qualitative investigation. Patient Education and Counseling 53 (2) 197-203.

Wilson, A., Duszynski, A., Turnbull, D. & Beilby, J. (2007). Investigating patients' and general practitioners' views of computerised decision support software for the assessment and management of cardiovascular risk. Available at: http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/bcs/ipc/2007/00000015/00000001/art00005 (Last accessed 24 June 2015)

Thomson, P., Dowding, D., Swanson, V., Bland, R., Mair, C., Morrison, A., Taylor, A., Beechev, C. & Niven, C.A. (2006). A computerised guidance tree (decision aid) for hypertension, based on decision analysis: development and preliminary evaluation. European Journal of Cardiovascular Nursing 5 (2) 146-149.

Green, M.J., McInerney, A.M., Biesecker, B.B. & Fost, N. (2001). Education about genetic testing for breast cancer susceptibility: Patient preferences for a computer program or genetic counselor. American Journal of Medical Genetics 103 (1) 24-31.

Ruland, C.M., Maffei, R.M., Borosund, E., Krahn, A., Andersen, T. & Grimsbo, G.H. (2013). Evaluation of different features of an eHealth application for personalized illness management support: Cancer patients’ use and appraisal of usefulness. International Journal of Medical Informatics 82 (7) 593-603.

Carroll, C., Marsden, P., Soden, P., Naylor, E., New, J. & Dornan, T. (2002). Involving users in the design and usability evaluation of a clinical decision support system. Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine 69 (2) 123-135.

Hoffmann, T., Russell, T. & McKenna, K. (2004). Producing computer-generated tailored written information for stroke patients and their carers: system development and preliminary evaluation. International Journal of Medical Informatics 73 (11) 751-758.

Ma, C., Warren, J., Phillips, P. & Stanek, J. (2006). Empowering patients with essential information and communication support in the context of diabetes. International Journal of Medical Informatics 75 (8) 577-596.

Grimsbo, G.H., Engelsrud, G.H., Ruland, C.M. & Finset, A. (2012). Cancer patients’ experiences of using an Interactive Health Communication Application (IHCA). International Journal of Qualitative Studies on Health and Well-being 7 1-14.

Feldman-Stewart, D., Obrien, M.A., Clayman, M.L., Davison, B.J., Jimbo, M., Labrecque, M., Martin, R.W. & Shepherd, H. (2013). Providing information about options in patient decision aids. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making 13 (Supplement 2) S4.

Graham, I.D., Logan, J., O'Connor, A., Weeks, K.E., Aaron, S., Cranney, A., Dales, R., Elmsie, T. (2003). A qualitative study of physicians' perceptions of three decision aids. Patient Education and Counseling 50 (3) 279-283.

Stacey, D., Kryworuchko, J., Belkora, J., Davison, B.J., Durand, M.A., Eden, K.B., Hoffman, A.S., Koerner, M., Légaré, F., Loiselle, M.C. & Street Jnr, R.L. (2013). Coaching and guidance with patient decision aids: A review of theoretical and empirical evidence. BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making 13 (Supplement 2) S11.

Elwyn, G., Lloyd, A., Joseph-Williams, N., Cording, E., Thomson, R., Durand, M.A & Edwards, A. (2011). Option Grids: Shared decision making made easier. Patient Education and Counseling 90 (2) 207-212.

Montori, V.M., Shah, N.D., Pencille, L.J., Branda, M.E., Van Houlton, H.K., Swiglo, B.A., Kesman, R.L., Tulledge-Scheitel, S.M., Jaeger, T.M., Johnson, R.E., Bartel, G.A., Melton 3rd, L.J. & Wermers, R.A. (2012). Use of a decision aid to improve treatment decisions in osteoporosis: the osteoporosis choice randomized trial. American Journal of Medicine 124 (6) 549-556.

Giguere, A., Légaré, F., Grad, R., Pluye, P., Haynes, R.B., Cauchon, M., Rousseau, F., Alvarez Argote, J. & Labrecque, M. (2012). Decision boxes for clinicians to support evidence-based practice and shared decision making: the user experience. Implementation Science 7 (1) 72.

Cabana, M.D., Rand, C.S., Powe, N.R., Wu, A.W., Wilson, M.H., Abboud, P.A. & Rubin, H.R. (1999) Why don't physicians follow clinical practice guidelines?: A framework for improvement. Journal of the American Medical Association 282 (15) 1458-1465.

van Tol-Geerdink, J.J., Stalmeier, P.F., van Lin, E.N., Schimmel, E.C., Huizenga, H., van Daal, W.A. & Leer, J.W. (2006). Do prostate cancer patients want to choose their own radiation treatment? International Journal of Radiation 66 (4) 1105-1111.

Brackett, C., Kearing, S., Cochran, N., Tosteson, A.N. & Blair Brooks, W. (2010). Strategies for distributing cancer screening decision aids in primary care. Patient Education and Counseling 78 (2) 166-168.

Légaré, F. & Witteman, H.O. (2013). Shared Decision Making: Examining Key Elements And Barriers To Adoption Into Routine Clinical Practice. Health Affairs 32 (2) 276-284.

Schrijvers, J., Vanderhaegen, J., Van Poppel, H., Haustermans, K. & Van Audenhove, C. (2012). How do patients between the age of 65 and 75 use a web-based decision aid for treatment choice in localized prostate cancer? Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine 6 (3) 167-172.

Frosch, D.L., May, S.G., Rendle, K.A.S., Tietbohl, C. & Elwyn, G. (2012). Authoritarian physicians and patients' fear of being labeled difficult among key obstacles to shared decision making. Health Affairs 31 (5) 1030-1038.

Menachemi, N., Burke, D.E. & Ayers, D.J. (2004). Factors affecting the adoption of telemedicine - a multiple adopter perspective. Journal of Medical Systems 28 (6) 617-632.

O'Connor, A.M. & Cranney, A. (2002). User Manual - Acceptability. Available at: https://decisionaid.ohri.ca/eval.html (last accessed 23 June 2015).




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5750/ejpch.v4i1.1064

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.